Psychology: Developmental psychology: Analysis of a phobia of a 5 year old boy

Psychology: Developmental psychology: Analysis of a phobia of a 5 year old boy

Author: Freud (1909)

Key term: Little Hans

Approach: Development psychology; psychodynamic perspective

Method: Case study and longitudinal method

Freud's psychodynamic approach:

• Our behaviours and feelings when we grow up (including psychological problems) are caused by childhood experiences.
• All behaviour is determined.

Personalities are made up of 3 parts: The ID (instinctive drive), ego and superego

• ID: Biological aspects of the personality. Consists of two forces:
        Eros: Life force - Instinct that drives us to do biological things - sex drive, eating, etc. Mainly revolves around libido (sex drive).
        Thanatos: Death force- Instinct of self-destruction.
  ID is chaotic and totally unreasonable (we cannot randomly have sex with people when we feel like it).
• Ego: Mediates between unrealistic ID and external real world. Decision making component of personality. Works out realistic ways of satisfying ID.
  "Part of the ID which has been modified by the direct influence of the external world" - Freud.
  Similar to ID, seeks pleasure and avoids pain but using a realistic strategy.
• Superego: Values and morals of society by influence of parents or role models. Strive for perfection. Develops at around the age of 3-5 during phallic stage of psychosexual development. Two systems:
      Conscious: Punishes the ego through feelings of guilt.
      Ideal self: Imaginary picture of how you ought to be; career aspirations, how to treat other people and how to behave as a member of society.

•  The ego and superego are largely determined by parental values and how you were brought up.

Freud's psychosexual development theory:

• Freud believed life was built around tension and pressure, which was due to the libido.
• What develops is the way sexual energy accumulates and builds up and is discharged as we mature biologically. 
• Each psychosexual stage has a particular conflict that must be resolved before continuing to the next stage. Some people may not be able to leave one stage and continue on to the next. This can be because the needs of the stage have not been met, causing frustration, or the pleasure is so good they don't want to leave, called overindulgence. 

1. Oral - The mouth - sucking, swallowing, etc. Ego develops.
2. Anal - The anus - withholding or excreting feces. 
3. Phallic - The penis or clitoris - masturbation. Superego develops.
4. Latent - Little or no sexual motivation.
5. Genital - The penis or vagina - Sexual intercourse.

Freud's Oedipus complex

• Oedipus - Greek myth where Oedipus, a young man, kills his father and marries his mother.
• The Oedipus complex is when a 3 - 5 year old boy develops sexual feelings for his mother, and therefore wants to get rid of his father so he can have his mother all to himself.
• This is usually resolved by the boy imitating his father's masculine type behaviours, called identification.
• Happens during phallic stage.
• Fred states that every boy goes through this complex to a certain extent.

Little Han's phobia case study

• 5 year old Jewish boy from Vienna, Austria.
• Phobia of horses
• Primary aim was to treat the phobia.
• Freud did not work directly with Hans. his father gave Freud all the details of Hans behavior when he suspected Hans was suffering from the Oedipus complex.

• At 3, Hans was very obsessed with his 'widdler' (penis), and also those of other people. He once asked his mother "Mommy, do you also have a widdler?". He played with it regularly until his mother threatened to call the doctor to get it cut off, which made him get castration anxiety. 
• At the same time, Hans saw a horse collapse and die in the street, and was very upset.

• At 4, Hans developed a fear of horses, specifically a fear that a white horse would bite him. 
• At the same time a conflict developed between him and his father. Hans had developed a habit of getting in to his parents bed in the morning to cuddle his mother. However, his father began to object and banned him from continuing.  
• Hans phobia worsened to the point that he would not leave the family house and he also suffered attacks of generalised anxiety.
• The anxiety Hans had was actually castration anxiety triggered by his mothers threat to cut off his "widdler" and fear of his father caused by his banishment from the parental bed. 

• Hans reported having the following dream; "In the night there was a big giraffe in the room and a crumpled one: and the big one called out because I took the crumpled one away from it. Then it stopped calling out: and I sat on top of the crumpled one."
• The giraffes in Hans dream represent his parents. The large giraffe is his father, and him crying out represented him objecting Hans. It's erect neck could have also been a penis symbol. The crumpled giraffe was his mother, and the crumpling represented her genitals. 

• When Hans was 5 his phobia of horses lessened, initially becoming limited to only white horses with black nose bands, then disappearing altogether.

• The horses represented Hans father, especially white horses with black nose bands, because they looked like his moustached father. Horses also have large penises, which make a good father symbol.s

• The end of the phobia was marked by two fantasies:
• Hans fantasised that he had several children. When his father asked who their mother was Hans replied "Why Mummy, and you're the granddaddy"
• This children fantasy represents a friendly resolution of the Oedipus complex, where he replaces his father but still keeps him in the family with the role as grandfather.
• The next day, Hans fantasised that a plumber had come and removed his bottom and penis, replacing them with new and larger ones. 
• The plumber fantasy represents identification with the father. Hans can see himself growing a large penis like his fathers and becoming like him.

Conclusion

Hans had a phobia of horses because he was suffering from castration anxiety and was going through the Oedipus complex. Hans dreams and fantasies helped express this conflict and eventually he resolved his phobia and Oedipus complex by identification by fantasising of himself taking on his fathers role and placing his father in the role of grandfather.

Strengths

• Case study - Lots of data can be collected because it is the study of one boy, so it is more valid.
• Natural observation - Hans was in his own house and not in any artificial setting, so there is a high level of ecological validity and mundane realism.

Weaknesses

• Unscientific - Freud's theory is considered unscientific because there is no evidence to back his theory.
• Generalization - Since it is the study of only one boy, we cannot generalize the oedipus theory to every boy.
• Bias - Freud published his theory before doing this case study, therefore he could have been bias. Hans father was a fan of Freud and believed in his theory, therefore he could've only told details that correlated to the study.
• Invalid - There could be many other reasons Hans had a phobia of horses. For example, when he was 3 he saw a horse fall in the street and die.